Cambridge And Beyond

News

We're ready to put your news up here.

Just send us your press releases and we'll do the rest. Click Here to e-mail you news or send it to


FATEA
PO Box 2218
Parkstone
Poole
BH17 7ZZ

Folk Students Respond To Criticism

Recently Paul Burgess hi-jacked his own review of Shepheard, Spiers & Watson’s CD (Living Tradition magazine) in order to indulge in an un-provoked and un-related snipe at some of the graduates from the Newcastle folk degree. He wrote ‘Some of them appeared to either know or care about the music they were playing’. He didn’t say ‘all graduates’, but that’s the impression the reader gets. Paul Burgess also accuses these unnamed graduates of only being interested in ‘show-biz’.

As a graduate of this degree (one of less than 20 so far) I cannot accept that any of us would know or care little about the music we play. The way the course is structured is like a normal academic degree course, except that students serve a four-year ‘apprenticeship’ as a folk musician at the same time. Students are constantly guided by people who have devoted their lives (either professionally or in their free time) to traditional music, in theoretical and practical senses. How could you fail to develop an enthusiasm for, and understanding of traditional music (if you didn’t already have one), while being surrounded by these people?

In my opinion, the ‘show-biz’ side was actually the weakest element of the course – I found the ‘Music Business’ module (common to most music courses at Newcastle) very disappointing and we were more or less left to develop stagecraft for ourselves.

Now most graduates are working in community projects promoting folk-arts, teaching and playing in sessions. We are just like everyone else with an enthusiasm for folk music. Quite a lot of people criticize the degree and those involved without reading the syllabus first. That’s very frustrating and very unfair!


The offending review:
http://www.folkmusic.net/htmfiles/webrevs/sprcd1042.htm

Andrew Cadie

More details of Andrew's music can be found at http://www.myspace.com/andrewcadie  

Living Tradition have also allowed the students a response via the letters page of their new edition